With the MLB season approaching, fantasy managers are meticulously scouring player pools to find the competitive edge that leads to a championship. While early rounds often feel like a consensus, the real difference-makers are found in the value picks—players whose projected production outweighs their current draft day cost. In his latest assessment for the 2026 fantasy baseball draft, ESPN’s Eric Karabell has identified a core group of players for his annual "Do Draft" list, headlined by reliable veterans like Logan Webb and Freddie Freeman.
The Strategy Behind the 2026 Fantasy Baseball Draft
Success in any 2026 fantasy baseball draft requires a balance between high-floor veterans and high-ceiling youngsters. Karabell’s "Do Draft" list isn't just a collection of the best players; it is a roadmap for finding value at every position. The focus this year is on identifying players who might be overlooked due to age, previous injury, or being part of a rebuilding roster, yet possess the underlying metrics to provide elite fantasy returns.
The list emphasizes the importance of volume and reliability. In an era of pitching rotations being managed more carefully than ever, workhorses like Logan Webb become invaluable assets. Similarly, consistent bats like Freddie Freeman provide the statistical foundation that allows managers to take risks on high-upside prospects later in the draft.
Pitching Pillars: Webb, Wheeler, and the Return of Strider
When building a rotation, the "Do Draft" list highlights Logan Webb of the San Francisco Giants as a primary target. Webb has established himself as one of the most durable arms in the league, consistently eating innings and providing a steady stream of quality starts. Joining him at the top of the wishlist is Philadelphia Phillies ace Zack Wheeler, who continues to defy aging curves with elite strikeout rates and command.
One of the most intriguing names on the list is Spencer Strider. After missing significant time, Strider represents a massive upside play for managers willing to bet on his health. The list also suggests looking toward Joe Ryan, Framber Valdez, and Nick Pivetta for mid-rotation stability. For those looking to solidify the back end of their bullpen, veterans Raisel Iglesias and Kenley Jansen remain priority targets, alongside emerging relief options like Emilio Pagan and Daniel Palencia.
Infield Stability: Why Freddie Freeman and Gunnar Henderson are Must-Haves
The infield is anchored by some of the most consistent names in the sport. Freddie Freeman remains a staple of the "Do Draft" philosophy because of his ability to contribute across all five standard categories. Despite being a veteran, his plate discipline and contact skills make him a safe bet to outperform younger, more volatile options.
The list also features high-end talent like Gunnar Henderson and Willy Adames, who provide power and speed from the shortstop position. Other notable infielders highlighted for their value include:
- Christian Walker: A power source at first base who often goes later than his production warrants.
- Jackson Holliday: A top prospect expected to take a massive leap in 2026.
- Zach Neto: An emerging star for the Angels with a burgeoning power-speed profile.
- Matt Chapman and Manny Machado: Veteran third basemen who offer elite defense and consistent home run totals.
- Bryson Stott and Jonathan Aranda: Middle infielders who offer flexibility and high contact rates.
Outfield Upside and Catching Depth
In the outfield, Yordan Alvarez remains the gold standard for pure hitting, but the 2026 value list looks deeper. Jackson Merrill and Roman Anthony represent the new wave of talent that fantasy managers should prioritize. Merrill’s multi-position eligibility and Anthony’s elite prospect pedigree make them excellent targets for those looking to inject youth into their rosters. Additionally, George Springer and Brenton Doyle are cited as players who can provide sneaky value in the middle rounds.
The catcher position, often a wasteland in fantasy, looks surprisingly deep this year. Will Smith leads the way as a high-floor option, but Karabell also points toward Ryan Jeffers and the emerging Drake Baldwin as players who can provide starting-caliber production without the premium price tag. By targeting these specific value points, managers can build a well-rounded roster capable of weathering the long MLB season.
Sources & Original Reporting
