The dust has finally settled on the 2026 NFL Draft, but while analysts and fans are busy handing out letter grades, the most intriguing insights are coming from a different source: the college coaches who spent years developing this talent. In a series of confidential interviews, coaches from powerhouse programs like the Alabama Crimson Tide, Ohio State Buckeyes, and Texas Tech Red Raiders shared their candid thoughts on which teams hit home runs and which picks left them scratching their heads. This insider perspective provides a unique look at how the next generation of NFL stars is viewed by those who know them best.
The Raiders and Jets Secure Elite Talent Early
The 2026 NFL Draft kicked off with a move that many saw coming but coaches still lauded for its perfect schematic fit. The Las Vegas Raiders selected Indiana Hoosiers quarterback Fernando Mendoza with the No. 1 overall pick. College coaches familiar with the Big 10 landscape noted that Mendoza’s pre-snap recognition and composure make him the ideal signal-caller for rookie coach Klint Kubiak’s system. One coach remarked that Mendoza possesses a rare level of mental toughness required to handle the unique spotlight and pressure of Las Vegas, suggesting he was the safest bet at the top of the board.
Not far behind, the New York Jets were the talk of the draft’s first day. By selecting Texas Tech edge rusher David Bailey at No. 2, the Jets added what one Big 12 coach described as "the most explosive pure pass rusher in the country." The Jets didn’t stop there, later adding Oregon tight end Kenyon Sadiq and Indiana wide receiver Omar Cooper Jr. to bolster their offensive arsenal. Coaches were particularly impressed by the "juice" the Jets added to their offense, noting that Cooper is a "shifty, slot-based player" who reminds many of Puka Nacua in his ability to create separation and gain yards after the catch.
Surprise Moves: The Rams and Cowboys Shake Up the Board
Perhaps the biggest shock of the first round came from the Los Angeles Rams. At pick No. 13, the Rams selected Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson. This move was characterized as a "stunner" by rival coaches, especially considering Simpson only had 15 starts under his belt in Tuscaloosa. While Rams GM Les Snead clearly saw first-round potential in Simpson's arm talent and mobility, coaches noted that even Simpson seemed surprised by the early call, having never met head coach Sean McVay prior to the draft. It represents a massive bet on raw traits over extensive starting experience.
The Dallas Cowboys also made waves with a rare trade with the Philadelphia Eagles to secure USC wide receiver Makai Lemon. Lemon, who initially believed he was headed to the Pittsburgh Steelers, brings elite playmaking ability to the Cowboys' vertical passing game. The Cowboys further bolstered their roster by acquiring Ohio State safety Caleb Downs via a trade with the Miami Dolphins. Coaches praised the Cowboys' strategic aggression, noting that Downs is a "blue-chip leader" who immediately improves any secondary he joins. His high football IQ and tackling range make him a Day 1 starter in the NFL.
Sleeper Picks and Value Steals: Coaches' Favorites
While the first round gets the headlines, college coaches often find the most value in the middle rounds where depth is built. Several coaches pointed to Tennessee Volunteers cornerback Jermod McCoy as the potential steal of the draft. McCoy, a top-10 talent who slid to the Las Vegas Raiders in the fourth round due to medical concerns, was described as an "elite ball-hawk" who will make teams regret passing on him if he stays healthy.
Jeremiyah Love, RB, Notre Dame
Selected by the Arizona Cardinals, coaches believe Love is a "slam dunk" acquisition. They highlighted his ability to boost Mike LaFleur’s offense immediately, citing his vision and lateral quickness as traits that translate perfectly to the professional level. He was frequently mentioned as a player who could outperform his draft slot in his rookie season.
Arvell Reese, Edge, Ohio State
Taken by the New York Giants, Reese is viewed by opposing Big Ten coaches as a hybrid playmaker with massive upside. His length and first-step explosiveness make him a nightmare for offensive tackles. Coaches noted that he is still scratching the surface of his potential, making him a high-value developmental piece for the Giants' defensive front.
Francis Mauigoa, OT, Miami
Another Giants pick that coaches loved, Mauigoa was cited for his physical dominance and pro-ready frame. Coaches who faced the Miami Hurricanes noted that Mauigoa is a "mauler" in the run game who possesses the footwork to handle elite NFL edge rushers. His transition to the professional game is expected to be smoother than most offensive line prospects.
Carnell Tate, WR, Ohio State
Heading to the Tennessee Titans, Tate was described by coaches as a "safe" pick with high-end WR1 potential. Known for his technical route running and reliable hands, Tate was a favorite among coaches for his consistency. One coach mentioned that Tate rarely makes the same mistake twice, a trait that will endear him to his new coaching staff in Tennessee.
Building for the Future
The feedback from the college ranks suggests that teams like the Arizona Cardinals and New York Jets prioritized high-floor athletes who can contribute on Day 1. Meanwhile, the Minnesota Vikings and Pittsburgh Steelers were noted for their disciplined approach, sticking to their boards even if they missed out on some of the flashier names early on. As these rookies head to minicamps, the consensus among college coaches is clear: the 2026 NFL Draft class has the depth and specific skill sets to reshape the league's hierarchy for years to come. Whether it's a first-round quarterback or a fourth-round cornerback, the impact of these players will be felt across the league as they transition from campus stars to NFL mainstays.
Sources & Original Reporting
