The sound of whistles and the sight of gold-and-black jerseys returned to the South Side on Tuesday, but two of the team's most promising young defenders were noticeably absent from live action. As the Pittsburgh Steelers opened their Steelers mandatory minicamp, both cornerback Joey Porter Jr. and outside linebacker Nick Herbig opted not to participate in team drills. While both players were present and in uniform, their decision to remain on the sidelines highlights a growing trend in the NFL: the 'hold-in.'
According to reports from the facility, the duo is currently awaiting contract extensions as they enter the final year of their respective rookie deals. By appearing at the facility and wearing their uniforms, Porter and Herbig avoid the heavy fines associated with missing a mandatory camp, yet they send a clear message to the front office regarding their desire for long-term financial security. This calculated move puts the spotlight on General Manager Omar Khan as the team prepares for the upcoming season.
The Strategic 'Hold-In' at Steelers Mandatory Minicamp
The concept of the 'hold-in' has become a popular leverage tool for players who want to negotiate new contracts without incurring the $100,000-plus fines that come with skipping Steelers mandatory minicamp. For Joey Porter Jr. and Nick Herbig, the move is a testament to their perceived value within the organization. Both players were integral parts of the 2023 draft class that has quickly become the bedrock of the Steelers' defensive identity.
Porter Jr., who shadowed some of the league's best wide receivers during his rookie campaign, has established himself as the team's undisputed CB1. Meanwhile, Herbig proved to be an incredibly efficient pass rusher in a rotational role, providing high-energy relief for stars T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith. With both players entering the final year of their rookie contracts, their representatives are likely looking to capitalize on their early-career success before the risk of injury in a contract year becomes a factor.
Impact on the Steelers Mandatory Minicamp and Defensive Depth
While the absence of Porter and Herbig from team periods is a storyline focused on finances, it also has immediate implications for the coaching staff. Head coach Mike Tomlin and defensive coordinator Teryl Austin must now utilize these reps to evaluate depth players who might otherwise see limited action. With Porter sidelined, the secondary gets an extended look at developmental cornerbacks and veteran additions fighting for a roster spot.
On the edge, Herbig’s lack of participation allows more snaps for the depth behind Highsmith and Watt. However, the Steelers' defense is at its best when its young core is building chemistry. The 2023 class, which also includes defensive tackle Keeanu Benton and tight end Darnell Washington, is expected to take a massive leap this year. Benton, in particular, was seen taking active reps on Tuesday, continuing his trajectory as a foundational piece of the interior defensive line.
The Business Side of the Gridiron
The Pittsburgh Steelers have a long-standing tradition of taking care of their own, but they typically prefer to finalize extensions during the window between minicamp and the start of training camp in late July. The decision by Porter and Herbig to start this process early by 'holding in' suggests that their camps may be looking for a swifter resolution.
For Alex Highsmith, who was present and fully active, the situation is a familiar one. Highsmith went through his own contract negotiations recently, eventually landing a deal that kept him in Pittsburgh long-term. The Steelers' front office now faces the challenge of balancing the salary cap while ensuring that their young, homegrown talent feels valued. Given the rising costs of premier cornerbacks and edge rushers in the NFL market, the price tag for Porter and Herbig is only likely to go up if they replicate their rookie-year production.
Looking Ahead to Training Camp at Saint Vincent College
As the Steelers mandatory minicamp continues through the week, all eyes will be on whether Porter and Herbig transition back into full participation or if the 'hold-in' persists until a deal is struck. The transition from minicamp to the grueling heat of training camp at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe is often the catalyst for contract resolutions.
The Steelers' defense projects to be one of the most formidable units in the league, provided their key contributors are on the field. With Keeanu Benton anchoring the middle and Darnell Washington providing a massive blocking presence on the offensive side, the pieces are in place for a deep postseason run. However, the business of football remains the primary hurdle for the Steelers this June. Fans and analysts alike will be watching the transaction wire closely to see if Omar Khan can lock down two of the team's most important young defensive pillars before the team heads to Latrobe.
Sources & Original Reporting
