The Colorado Avalanche are facing a significant test of their roster depth as superstar defenseman Cale Makar is expected to miss "a few games" following a Cale Makar upper-body injury. The news, confirmed by the team following their recent victory over the Calgary Flames, comes at a critical juncture in the NHL season as the Avalanche look to solidify their standing in a highly competitive Western Conference.
Makar, a perennial Norris Trophy candidate and a cornerstone of Colorado’s transition game, reportedly sustained the injury during the team's hard-fought win against Calgary earlier this week. While the organization has been characteristically vague regarding the specific nature of the ailment, head coach Jared Bednar provided a timeline that suggests the team is taking a cautious approach with their franchise pillar. The loss of Makar, even for a short period, forces the Avalanche to rethink their defensive pairings and power-play strategies during a vital stretch of the schedule.
Understanding the Timeline and Recovery
The "upper-body" designation is a staple of NHL injury reporting, often used to protect players from being targeted upon their return. However, the projection of "a few games" offers a glimmer of hope for Avalanche fans. It suggests that the medical staff does not view this as a long-term setback that would require a stint on the Long-Term Injured Reserve (LTIR). Instead, the focus is on rest and rehabilitation to ensure Makar is at full strength for the final push toward the postseason.
Coach Bednar emphasized that while Makar is a competitor who rarely wants to miss time, the long-term health of the player is the priority. The Avalanche have dealt with a litany of injuries to key players over the last two seasons, and their medical staff has become adept at managing workloads to prevent minor issues from becoming season-ending catastrophes. For now, Makar will likely be monitored on a day-to-day basis following this initial "few games" window.
The Tactical Impact of the Cale Makar Upper-Body Injury
It is impossible to overstate what Makar brings to the ice. He is not just a defenseman; he is a primary engine for the Avalanche offense. His elite skating ability allows him to act as a fourth forward, leading rushes and creating odd-man advantages that few other players in the league can replicate. Without him, the Avalanche lose their most potent weapon from the blue line, which will inevitably lead to a dip in their transition speed.
The power play is perhaps where the Cale Makar upper-body injury will be felt most acutely. Makar serves as the "quarterback" of the top unit, using his lateral movement and vision to open up passing lanes for Nathan MacKinnon and Mikko Rantanen. His ability to walk the blue line and deliver pucks through traffic is a unique skill set that keeps opposing penalty killers on their heels. In his absence, Colorado will need to find a way to maintain their man-advantage efficiency using different looks and personnel.
Filling the Void: Who Steps Up for Colorado?
With the league's most dynamic defenseman out of the lineup, the responsibility shifts to the remaining members of the defensive corps. Jared Bednar will need several players to elevate their game to cover the nearly 25 minutes of ice time Makar typically absorbs.
Devon Toews
As Makar’s long-time defensive partner, Devon Toews is the natural candidate to take on an even larger role. Toews is already an elite, all-situations defender, but he will now be tasked with carrying more of the puck-moving responsibilities. His steady presence will be vital in stabilizing the top pairing while the team experiments with different partners to fill Makar's spot.
Samuel Girard
Samuel Girard is perhaps the player best suited to mimic Makar’s style of play. Known for his exceptional edge work and ability to evade forecheckers, Girard is the leading candidate to take over the point on the top power-play unit. This stretch represents a major opportunity for Girard to prove he can handle top-pairing minutes and drive the offense from the back end.
Josh Manson
While Girard provides the finesse, Josh Manson provides the grit. In the absence of Makar, Manson’s role as a shutdown defender becomes even more critical. He will likely see an increase in defensive zone starts and be expected to clear the front of the net against the opposition's top scoring lines, providing the physical stability the team needs while shorthanded.
Sam Malinski
The young Sam Malinski has shown flashes of offensive brilliance during his time with the big club. With a spot open in the top six, Malinski will get a chance to showcase his poise and shooting ability. His development is a silver lining in this situation, as the Avalanche look to build more depth for a deep playoff run.
Looking Ahead at the Avalanche Schedule
The timing of the injury is less than ideal, as the Avalanche face several divisional rivals over the next week. These matchups are often "four-point games" that can determine home-ice advantage in the playoffs. However, the Avalanche have a proven track record of the "next man up" mentality. They have won games without their captain Gabriel Landeskog and have navigated previous absences of stars like MacKinnon.
The focus for the coaching staff will be on simplifying the game. Without Makar’s ability to bail the team out with individual brilliance, the Avalanche must rely on a structured defensive system and disciplined puck management. If the team can tread water and maintain their position in the standings during this short-term absence, they will be in an excellent position once their superstar returns to the ice at 100% health.
Sources & Original Reporting
