In the world of professional sports, narratives often move faster than reality. Few players understand this better than Baker Mayfield. Currently enjoying a career resurgence with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, the former No. 1 overall pick still finds himself at the center of debates regarding his four-year stint with the Cleveland Browns. Recently, ESPN’s Mike Greenberg took to the airwaves to offer a staunch defense of Mayfield, arguing that the quarterback has every right to be frustrated with how his time in Cleveland is remembered.
Mike Greenberg Challenges the Baker Mayfield Narrative
On a recent segment of ESPN’s "Get Up," Mike Greenberg addressed the lingering criticism of Baker Mayfield’s tenure in Cleveland. Greenberg’s central argument is that the history of Mayfield’s time with the Browns is being rewritten to favor the organization's decision to move on, rather than reflecting the objective success Mayfield brought to a historically struggling franchise.
Greenberg emphasized that Mayfield’s frustrations are not just personal—they are justified by the facts. When Mayfield arrived in Cleveland in 2018, he joined a team that had just completed a winless 0-16 season. Within three years, he had led them to the divisional round of the AFC playoffs. According to Greenberg, the way that narrative has shifted from "franchise savior" to "disposable asset" is a misrepresentation of what actually occurred on the field.
Setting the Record Straight: Mayfield’s Cleveland Success
To understand why Mike Greenberg is coming to Mayfield's defense, one must look at the state of the Cleveland Browns before and during his tenure. Before Mayfield, the Browns were a revolving door of quarterbacks and losing seasons. Mayfield broke that cycle almost immediately.
- The 2018 Turnaround: As a rookie, Mayfield set a then-record for passing touchdowns by a rookie (27) and led the Browns to seven wins, their most in over a decade.
- The 2020 Playoff Run: Mayfield led Cleveland to an 11-5 record and a historic Wild Card victory over the Pittsburgh Steelers—the franchise’s first playoff win since the 1994 season.
- Cultural Impact: He provided a level of swagger and leadership that the city had lacked at the position for nearly thirty years.
Greenberg argues that these achievements are often glossed over by critics who focus solely on the friction that occurred during Mayfield’s final season in 2021.
The Role of Injury in the 2021 Fallout
A significant portion of the defense regarding Baker Mayfield involves the injury he sustained during the 2021 season. Early in the year, Mayfield suffered a torn labrum in his non-throwing shoulder. Rather than opting for immediate surgery, he chose to play through the pain in an attempt to help the team return to the postseason.
That decision, while courageous, proved to be a turning point in his reputation. His statistical performance dipped as he struggled with physical limitations, leading to increased criticism from the local media and, eventually, a rift with the front office. Greenberg points out that holding that specific season against Mayfield—while ignoring the physical toll he was taking for the team—is a primary reason why the quarterback has a right to be upset.
Why Mayfield Has a Right to be Upset
The frustration for Mayfield likely stems from the lack of loyalty shown by the Browns organization following that injury-plagued season. Instead of allowing their franchise quarterback to heal and return to his 2020 form, the Cleveland Browns aggressively pursued Deshaun Watson, effectively ending the Mayfield era in a public and messy fashion.
Since leaving Cleveland, Mayfield has had to rebuild his career from the ground up, moving through Carolina and Los Angeles before finding stability with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Meanwhile, the Browns have struggled to find consistent success with Watson. Greenberg suggests that seeing the organization struggle while he flourishes in Tampa Bay validates Mayfield’s perspective: he wasn't the problem in Cleveland; he was the solution that they discarded too quickly.
The Redemption in Tampa Bay
Today, Baker Mayfield is proving his supporters right. In his first season with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, he threw for over 4,000 yards and led the team to an NFC South title and a playoff win. His success in a different system, under different leadership, reinforces the idea that his struggles in his final Cleveland year were an outlier caused by injury and organizational dysfunction.
As Mike Greenberg concluded, the representation of Mayfield’s Browns tenure should be one of triumph over a losing culture, rather than a cautionary tale of a failed draft pick. For Mayfield, the best defense against his critics remains his play on the field, but having major media voices like Greenberg speak up for his legacy certainly helps set the record straight.
Sources & Original Reporting
